Your 18Forty Parsha Guide is a weekly newsletter exploring five major takeaways from the weekly parsha. Receive this newsletter every week in your inbox by subscribing here. Questions or feedback? Email Rivka Bennun Kay at Shabbosreads@18forty.org.
The first time Yitzchak speaks in Parshat Toldot, he’s lying to a foreign king about his wife. Sound familiar? His father Avraham did the exact same thing. Twice. The apple, it seems, doesn’t fall far from the tree.
Parshat Toldot reads like a masterclass in intergenerational family dynamics. Yitzchak and Rivka create the same favoritism dynamic that fractured Avraham and Sarah’s household. Yitzchak is repeating a pattern he grew up observing. Yaakov deceives his father just as Rivka orchestrates the deception. Esav marries women who cause his parents grief, creating new fractures in an already troubled family system. Beyond demonstrating that family patterns repeat, the parsha shows us the mechanics of their repetition and what is required to interrupt them.
What makes this week’s parsha remarkable isn’t just that it shows us dysfunction, rather that it does so with unflinching honesty. The Torah doesn’t sanitize its heroes, nor does it present Avraham’s family as a model to aspire to but as a mirror to recognize ourselves in. For anyone who has ever wondered why they repeat patterns they swore they’d never replicate, or why family dynamics persist despite everyone’s best intentions to change them, Parshat Toldot offers both diagnosis and hope.
1. Biology and Biography: How Trauma Gets Transmitted
When Yitzchak lies to Avimelech about Rivka being his sister, he’s doing exactly what his father did—twice. Avraham told this lie to Pharaoh in Egypt and later to another Avimelech in Gerar. The Torah doesn’t explain Yitzchak’s motivation, but the repetition is striking. It’s as if Yitzchak is running Avraham’s playbook without even realizing it.
Previous 18Forty Podcast guest Rachel Yehuda has researched how trauma gets transmitted across generations. Her work with Holocaust survivors revealed that biological stress responses can be passed through epigenetic changes—alterations in how genes are expressed. For Yitzckak, this inheritance is dramatic. The Akedah left him marked by near-death at his father’s hands, but Yitzchak’s trauma didn’t start there. Avraham experienced exile, famine, conflict, and dislocation. Yitzchak inherited baseline vulnerability from Avraham’s traumas, then the Akedah compounded everything. When Yitzchak lies about Rivka, he’s operating from overwhelming trauma, possibly amplified by inherited threat sensitivity.
The Torah’s geographic detail underscores this. God explicitly tells Yitzchak not to go down to Egypt but to stay in Gerar. Yet Gerar is precisely where Avraham had his encounter with Avimelech. Yitzchak isn’t just psychologically repeating his father’s pattern; he’s literally walking in his father’s footsteps, returning to the scene of ancestral trauma. Place and context trigger inherited responses in powerful ways.
Yet the story also hints at transformation. When Yitzchak reopens his father’s wells, he’s honoring his inheritance while doing his own labor. He’s not rejecting what came before, but he’s not passively accepting it either. This becomes the model: to acknowledge what you’ve inherited and understand its impact, which then allows you to consciously choose what to keep and what to change.
2. Parental Favoritism and Breaking the Pattern
The Torah states it plainly: “Yitzchak loved Esav … but Rivka loved Yaakov.” This isn’t the first time we’ve seen this pattern. Avraham and Sarah’s household was fractured by favoritism. Sarah favors Yitzchak, Avraham shows affection to Yishmael, and the family splits. Yitzchak witnesses this firsthand. He watches as his mother expels his half-brother. He knows what favoritism costs. Yet here he is, creating the exact same dynamic with his own children.
On 18Forty’s ongoing series exploring intergenerational divergence, guests repeatedly emphasize: More than favoritism destroys the sibling relationship, it damages both children’s sense of self. The favored child learns that love is conditional on performance. The unfavored child learns they’re fundamentally unworthy.
What’s particularly painful is that both Yitzchak and Rivka likely believed they were doing the right thing. Yitzchak may have favored Esav because he saw in him the kind of son he thought he should have been for Avraham—strong, capable in the physical world, traditionally masculine. Rivka may have favored Yaakov because she recognized in him something of herself, or because God had told her “the older shall serve the younger.” But good intentions don’t prevent damage. The reality isn’t from sibling rivalry, rather it’s from both children knowing they’re competing for parental love that should be freely given.
Breaking these patterns requires recognizing them first. Yitzchak never seems to acknowledge what he’s doing. There’s no moment in the text where he reflects on how his favoritism mirrors what he experienced growing up. Without that recognition, change is impossible. For families today, this might mean asking uncomfortable questions: Which child do I identify with more? Which child triggers me? Am I unconsciously recreating dynamics from my own childhood?
Some families manage to interrupt the pattern mid-stream. Yitzchak later blesses both sons. It’s not perfect repair, but it’s something—an acknowledgment that both children deserve blessing. Sometimes the best we can do is partial course correction: recognizing the pattern, naming the damage, and making whatever repair we can, even if it’s late.
3. Deception as Family Language: When You Can’t Say What You Mean
The climax of Parshat Toldot involves an elaborate deception. Yaakov, coached by his mother Rivka, impersonates Esav to steal his brother’s blessing. It’s a morally complex moment that has troubled commentators for millennia.
But zoom out and notice: Deception isn’t an anomaly in this family, but the language they speak. Yitzchak deceives Avimelech about Rivka. God tells Rivka that “the older shall serve the younger”—a clear prophecy about Yaakov’s destiny. Yet she still orchestrates deception to ensure Yaakov receives Yitzchak’s blessing. Perhaps she didn’t trust that divine promises would materialize without human intervention. Her decision suggests an operating system built on the idea that you can’t trust that things will work out on their own.
This pattern replicates across the family. The lesson that manipulating works gets transmitted to Yaakov, who will spend much of his life both being deceived by others and deceiving in turn: deceived by Lavan about Leah and Rachel, deceiving Yitzchak about Esav’s blessing. The family narrative becomes a message that this is how you get what you need.
Rashi notes that Yitzchak’s blindness may have been caused by the smoke from Esav’s wives’ idolatrous practices. But perhaps there’s another kind of blindness at work: the blindness that comes from unexamined family patterns. Yitzchak can’t see what he’s perpetuating because he’s never stepped back to examine how the patterns he witnessed from his father—the deception, the favoritism—are now shaping his own household.
For some families, breaking these patterns requires honest conversation about unspoken rules. But sometimes maintaining certain silences is wiser—not every truth needs to be spoken if it would cause harm without possibility of repair.
4. When Families Forget Blessing and Love Are Infinite
At the heart of the drama in Toldot lies a false belief: that there’s only one blessing to give. Yitzchak plans to bless Esav. Rivka schemes to steal it for Yaakov. The brothers become mortal enemies over it. But step back and ask: Did Yitzchak really have only one blessing to offer?
The patriarchs before him blessed multiple children. Avraham blessed both Yitzchak and Yishmael. Yaakov himself will later bless all 12 of his sons. There was never just one blessing to distribute. But families operating from scarcity can’t see this. They turn sibling relationships into zero-sum competitions.
This scarcity mindset creates a communication breakdown. When you believe there’s not enough blessing to go around, you can’t have honest conversations. You manipulate instead of negotiate. Notice what doesn’t happen in Toldot: Rivka never discusses the prophecy with Yitzchak. Yitzchak never tells Rivka he plans to bless Esav. The parents don’t talk to each other about their opposing preferences for their sons. The family operates through a combination of secrets and manipulation rather than direct communication.
The silence itself is telling. Families stuck in destructive patterns often have narratives built around scarcity, a belief that there isn’t enough love, success, or parental approval to go around. This scarcity belief makes honest conversation feel dangerous.
The truth is that blessing multiplies, it doesn’t divide. Avraham blesses both Yitzchak and Yishmael, and Yaakov later blesses all 12 sons. When families internalize this—that there really is enough for all—honest conversation becomes possible. Parents can grieve one child’s choices while celebrating another’s without making them rivals.
5. How All Children Carry Family Wounds
Here’s what’s easy to miss about favoritism: Both children suffer. Yaakov, the favored child, spends his life anxious and manipulative, always looking over his shoulder. Esav, the unfavored one, becomes reactive and rageful, feeling perpetually wronged. Neither favoritism nor rejection produces healthy adults. Both carry wounds into the next generation.
But there’s another dimension worth exploring: Yitzchak is an only child after Yishmael’s expulsion. He doesn’t have the complication of sibling rivalry, yet he still carries profound wounds from his childhood. When Esav marries women “who were a source of bitterness to Yitzchak and Rivka,” we see Yitzchak’s pain—but we also see how his unprocessed trauma affects his children. Without a sibling to share the burden or blame, the only child carries the full weight of parental expectations and disappointments.
The favored child learns that love is conditional, that they must perform to maintain their status. Yaakov becomes defined by his ability to please Rivka and by his conflict with his brother. The unfavored child learns that nothing they do will ever be enough. Esav tries to please Yitzchak (becoming a hunter, the kind of son Yitzchak values), yet Yitzchak’s preference never shifts.
What’s crucial for parents to understand is that you can’t “win” by choosing a favorite. The favored child doesn’t escape unscathed, instead they carry different wounds. And those wounds shape how they’ll parent their own children. Yaakov’s anxiety gets transmitted to his sons. His favoritism of Yosef nearly destroys his family, replicating the very pattern that wounded him.
For parents reading this: The work isn’t just about treating children equally, although that is an important component. It’s about examining your own wounds so you don’t unconsciously pass them forward. It’s about recognizing when your reaction to one child is really about your own childhood, your own parents, your own unresolved pain. It requires looking at parts of yourself you might prefer to avoid. But it’s also the most important work you can do.
For adult children reading this: Understanding that both favored and unfavored children carry wounds doesn’t erase your pain, but it might create compassion—for both your siblings and your parents, as well as for yourself. The question is, what do you want to do with that understanding?
Questions for Reflection:
- The Torah shows Yitzchak repeating Avraham’s mistakes. Does this mean we’re doomed to repeat our parents’ errors?
- If Rivka knew from prophecy that Yaakov would prevail over Esav, why did she feel the need to orchestrate the deception? Doesn’t this show a lack of faith?
- How can we honor our family heritage while also breaking destructive patterns? Isn’t there a tension there?
This project is made possible with support from the Simchat Torah Challenge and UJA-Federation of New York. Learn more about the Simchat Torah Challenge and get involved at their website.
